GeorgeReid
Reviews
Filter & sort
GeorgeReid
A (Mostly) Solid Scent for a Great Value
Everyone coming here knows that Club de Nuit Intense Man is a clone of Creed Aventus.
However, I will not review CDNIM as how it compares to Creed Aventus. Instead, I will review it based on its own merits.
----
The opening smell is the major point of critique. The artificial lemon in the opening smells like a household cleaner, with a minuscule hint of pineapple. Some people may like it (or even love it), but I dislike it. If the opening was tamer with a herbal note such as lavender, mint, or sage, it would go over better.
(Update on January 6, 2023: After letting the scent sit for a few months, the harshness of the lemon opening is gone, leaving a citrusy-sweet opening that is significantly more appealing.)
However, when one waits for about 15-20 minutes, the lemon aspect dies down, and the scent becomes great. The floral and smoky heart combine with musk and patchouli to form a spectacular masculine fragrance that shines without being overwhelming.
----
Also, I must discuss the bottle, which is cheap. In addition to looking tacky, the plastic peeled after owning it for a few months, and shows signs of wear and tear; something I don't see with any other bottles I currently own.
Also, the logo tag became unglued, and the chain connecting the logo tag to the bottle actually broke.
----
In terms of performance, CDNIM is exceptional.
The smell lasted beyond 10 hours. That is amazing longevity.
The fragrance also projects at a strong level. If you walk by someone on the street, or stay in one place for a decent amount of time, someone will discover the fragrance.
That said, if someone is trying to be subtle, CDNIM EDP isn't it. People are going to know it's you.
----
The contentious opening and the notoriously cheap bottle, are potential deal-breakers. Likewise, people who like more subtle scents may want to pass on this one.
That said, CDNIM provides outstanding value with a fragrance that is versatile, durable, and usable through most the year. The fact that it is affordable is a bonus.
(Update on January 6, 2023: The scent is significantly better, to the point I would currently rate it a 8.5/10. However, it is unrealistic to have someone wait months for a fragrance to reach its full potential.)
(Update on April 10, 2024: I eventually gave away the bottle. While it was a solid scent, I used it less in favor of milder scents.)
----
Edited on April 19, 2022 to add fragrance links to the reviews.
Edited again on May 4, 2022 to add notes about the bottle.
Added notes on the smell change on January 6, 2023.
Edited again on April 10, 2024 to shorten the review.
However, I will not review CDNIM as how it compares to Creed Aventus. Instead, I will review it based on its own merits.
----
The opening smell is the major point of critique. The artificial lemon in the opening smells like a household cleaner, with a minuscule hint of pineapple. Some people may like it (or even love it), but I dislike it. If the opening was tamer with a herbal note such as lavender, mint, or sage, it would go over better.
(Update on January 6, 2023: After letting the scent sit for a few months, the harshness of the lemon opening is gone, leaving a citrusy-sweet opening that is significantly more appealing.)
However, when one waits for about 15-20 minutes, the lemon aspect dies down, and the scent becomes great. The floral and smoky heart combine with musk and patchouli to form a spectacular masculine fragrance that shines without being overwhelming.
----
Also, I must discuss the bottle, which is cheap. In addition to looking tacky, the plastic peeled after owning it for a few months, and shows signs of wear and tear; something I don't see with any other bottles I currently own.
Also, the logo tag became unglued, and the chain connecting the logo tag to the bottle actually broke.
----
In terms of performance, CDNIM is exceptional.
The smell lasted beyond 10 hours. That is amazing longevity.
The fragrance also projects at a strong level. If you walk by someone on the street, or stay in one place for a decent amount of time, someone will discover the fragrance.
That said, if someone is trying to be subtle, CDNIM EDP isn't it. People are going to know it's you.
----
The contentious opening and the notoriously cheap bottle, are potential deal-breakers. Likewise, people who like more subtle scents may want to pass on this one.
That said, CDNIM provides outstanding value with a fragrance that is versatile, durable, and usable through most the year. The fact that it is affordable is a bonus.
(Update on January 6, 2023: The scent is significantly better, to the point I would currently rate it a 8.5/10. However, it is unrealistic to have someone wait months for a fragrance to reach its full potential.)
(Update on April 10, 2024: I eventually gave away the bottle. While it was a solid scent, I used it less in favor of milder scents.)
----
Edited on April 19, 2022 to add fragrance links to the reviews.
Edited again on May 4, 2022 to add notes about the bottle.
Added notes on the smell change on January 6, 2023.
Edited again on April 10, 2024 to shorten the review.
Outstanding, but it May Not be The One for You
When I started looking into fragrance, one fragrance that women recommended consistently was Dolce & Gabanna's The One.
After reading online reviews from several fragrance sites (including Parfumo), I took a shot in the dark and bought it blind.
----
The One EdP is an excellent blend of spices, woods, and amber. Overall, it hits the mark on the spices to where it's sensual, and not gourmand-ish. It also hits the mark on being resinous and woody, without being overly sweet.
If you are into spicy scents, or woody/resinous notes in a fragrance, The One EDP is an outstanding scent.
----
Despite the outstanding smell, the biggest complaint about The One EDP is performance.
The sillage and projection are mild, which is great for intimate moments. However, someone trying to seek attention at a bar or nightclub would find this unacceptable.
However, the bigger point of critique is the lack of longevity. The One EDP only lasts a maximum of 4-6 hours.
----
In my opinion, The One EDP is an exceptional fragrance that is perfect for a date night, or an intimate encounter. The lack of sillage also makes it workable as a daily scent in cooler weather, and not obnoxious in warmer weather.
That said, if you are looking for an enduring fragrance to wear for an all-night affair, or a fragrance to draw attention, look elsewhere; The One EDP isn't for you.
However, at the price range of discounters, The One EDP is a steal if the scent profile fits your style, and is an excellent option for a beginner.
----
Edited on April 10, 2024 to simplify the review.
After reading online reviews from several fragrance sites (including Parfumo), I took a shot in the dark and bought it blind.
----
The One EdP is an excellent blend of spices, woods, and amber. Overall, it hits the mark on the spices to where it's sensual, and not gourmand-ish. It also hits the mark on being resinous and woody, without being overly sweet.
If you are into spicy scents, or woody/resinous notes in a fragrance, The One EDP is an outstanding scent.
----
Despite the outstanding smell, the biggest complaint about The One EDP is performance.
The sillage and projection are mild, which is great for intimate moments. However, someone trying to seek attention at a bar or nightclub would find this unacceptable.
However, the bigger point of critique is the lack of longevity. The One EDP only lasts a maximum of 4-6 hours.
----
In my opinion, The One EDP is an exceptional fragrance that is perfect for a date night, or an intimate encounter. The lack of sillage also makes it workable as a daily scent in cooler weather, and not obnoxious in warmer weather.
That said, if you are looking for an enduring fragrance to wear for an all-night affair, or a fragrance to draw attention, look elsewhere; The One EDP isn't for you.
However, at the price range of discounters, The One EDP is a steal if the scent profile fits your style, and is an excellent option for a beginner.
----
Edited on April 10, 2024 to simplify the review.
2 Comments
