Foren-Übersicht Men's Perfume So many great vetivers...
Sherapop
Sherapop
1366 Posts
SherapopSherapop 28.01.2012, 21:23
Apicius wrote:

The Berlin Maison Guerlain was opened in summer last year, and Sylvaine Delacourte, Guerlain's art director, attended the event. Coriolon asked her whether there was a change or not, and she did not give a straight answer!


Sad to say, but the director's evasiveness on the matter does not surprise me in the least, given the general disarray of that house at this point in time. The managerial missteps have proliferated to the point where I have been forced lamentably to conclude that "Guerlain" is not Guerlain anymore.

Crying or Very sad

Sherapop
Sherapop
1366 Posts
SherapopSherapop 28.01.2012, 21:28
AromiErotici wrote:


sherapop, have you tried the Corinto Vetyver ( original ) ???


I have not, Aromi, but I'm going to go read your review!
Cool

DieNase
DieNase
4001 Posts
DieNaseDieNase 29.01.2012, 21:36
Sherapop wrote:
I had a big bottle of Guerlain Vetiver (vintage), which I loved and so gave it to a friend in a rare gesture of perfumic magnanimity. Rolling Eyes

Unfortunately, he proceeded to give it away--not because he loved it, but because he did not! Lesson learned: make no assumptions when it comes to perfume!

More recently, I have tried a slew of the new vetivers, including many of the ones some people have mentioned above, but I have one question for you all:

Is Hermessence Vetiver Tonka the only sweet vetiver around? I think that I might like it, if I were to wear it a few more times, but at the moment it strikes me as slightly odd simply for its sweetness. Maybe it's a case like salted licorice: an acquired taste?

Cool


To me, "Fat Electrician" has a sweet vibe, but not in a gourmand manner. Smoky as well (contrary to Vétiver Tonka, which unfortunately isn't smoky on my skin)

Apicius
Apicius
3421 Posts
ApiciusApicius 20.04.2012, 23:20
I just had a litttle splash of "Royall Vetiver", and I just want to mention that this simple Cologne reminds me a lot of the old Guerlain Vetiver before the Millennium reformulation.

Lola82
Lola82
338 Posts
Lola82Lola82 21.04.2012, 01:02
This Hasn't been Mentioned but have you ever tried
http://www.parfumo.net/Perfumes/Azzaro/Pure_Vetiver
to me it has a Hybrid of Pure/Synthetic Vetiver
Also http://www.parfumo.net/Perfumes/Lalique/Encre_Noire has rain
soaked Vetiver.

Sherapop
Sherapop
1366 Posts
SherapopSherapop 21.04.2012, 02:44
Lola82 wrote:
Also http://www.parfumo.net/Perfumes/Lalique/Encre_Noire has rain
soaked Vetiver.


Hmmm... is rain-soaked? Or is it toner cartridge fluid-soaked?
I find it oddly attractive, but I can only wear it about once every couple of months... something about the "encre" aspect

Twisted Evil

Lola82
Lola82
338 Posts
Lola82Lola82 21.04.2012, 05:34
Naughty naughty miss Shera want me to give you a spanking
and put you up for bed without dinner for sabotaging my
sermon on Encre noir rain soaked Vetiver HEHEHEHEHE
Just Joking well that's a good description

Apicius
Apicius
3421 Posts
ApiciusApicius 21.04.2012, 09:59
No, I do not like Enré Noir at all. It has fy far too much Cashmerean - a synthetic note should go through as woody.

Cashmerean has a smell of charcoal on a barbecue after being lit off with a bucket of water - a liquoricy smear. Nevertheless, it can be good when handled with consideration.

Sherapop
Sherapop
1366 Posts
SherapopSherapop 21.04.2012, 16:17
Apicius wrote:
No, I do not like Enré Noir at all. It has fy far too much Cashmerean - a synthetic note should go through as woody.

Cashmerean has a smell of charcoal on a barbecue after being lit off with a bucket of water - a liquoricy smear. Nevertheless, it can be good when handled with consideration.


Thanks for clearing this mystery up, Apicius. That must be what bothers me about it. I never understand when I read people saying that "Encre Noire" is a "clean vetiver". What? Rolling Eyes

In my review, I said something like it reminds me of glue-sniffing or standing by the gas pump as fumes waft off the nozzle. I read someone else who described it as perfume for "Darth Vader". That seems about right to me. Twisted Evil

Cool

Sherapop
Sherapop
1366 Posts
SherapopSherapop 21.04.2012, 16:21
DieNase wrote:
"Infusion de Vétiver" - the vetiver kicks in very late, don't give up early.


I just got this one, and I have to say that I love it. I also got the bath gel and it is fantastic for a long, hot soak!

But I somewhat suspect that "Infusion de Vetiver" is the vetiver for vetiver haters because it seems quite low on that note relative to other colognes/perfumes said to be vetiver-centric. I smell a pretty hefty dose of tarragon, which is gorgeous to my nose...

Cool

Apicius
Apicius
3421 Posts
ApiciusApicius 21.04.2012, 19:50
Sherapop wrote:
I never understand when I read people saying that "Encre Noire" is a "clean vetiver". What? Rolling Eyes
There is a considerable difference between vetiver oil and vetiveryl acetate. The acetate is what we recognize as vetiver in perfumes. Once I had the chance to compare both: The oil is rough, smoky and not pleasant at all. I suppose there might be something of that in Encré Noir.

Sherapop
Sherapop
1366 Posts
SherapopSherapop 21.04.2012, 20:02
Apicius wrote:
Sherapop wrote:
I never understand when I read people saying that "Encre Noire" is a "clean vetiver". What? Rolling Eyes
There is a considerable difference between vetiver oil and vetiveryl acetate. The acetate is what we recognize as vetiver in perfumes. Once I had the chance to compare both: The oil is rough, smoky and not pleasant at all. I suppose there might be something of that in Encré Noir.


Hmmm... so do you think that "clean vetiver" is supposed to mean "neat vetiver"

Question


21.04.2012, 20:10
I am surprised nobody has mentioned the Vetiver from Le Labo as of yet.
That's one I personally like.
Encre Noire is one I like to wear as well though
Foto hinzufügen


Apicius
Apicius
3421 Posts
ApiciusApicius 21.04.2012, 20:12
Sherapop, I just wanted to point out that what we consider a clean vetiver is apparently not the pure stuff.

Larimar
Larimar
401 Posts
LarimarLarimar 22.04.2012, 08:00
Racine is (maybe) all I ask for when it comes to vetiver-centered frags.

Scentimental
Scentimental
127 Posts
ScentimentalScentimental 24.01.2013, 01:50
I have Guerlain Vetiver Extreme, which I love because it has great longevity and sillage and now I find out it's been discontinued! I had better stock up on some back up bottles! Sad

Cincy
Cincy
2385 Posts
CincyCincy 24.01.2013, 03:21
I have the vintage Guerlain Vetiver, my favorite.

Drseid
Drseid
92 Posts
DrseidDrseid 03.02.2013, 13:12
Vetiver has got to be one of my three favorite notes... Probably my favorite compositions that feature it are:

The LesNez Turtle Vetiver trio (Exercise 1, Front and Back)
Anat Fritz (original version) by Anat Fritz
Les Nombres d'Or Vetyver by Mona di Orio
Coeur de Vetiver Sacre by L'Artisan
The Supercilium and Subcilium sister scents by O'driu
No.89 (vintage) by Floris
Bursch by Acqua di Biella

Apicius
Apicius
3421 Posts
ApiciusApicius 03.02.2013, 14:06
Scentimental wrote:
I have Guerlain Vetiver Extreme, which I love because it has great longevity and sillage and now I find out it's been discontinued! I had better stock up on some back up bottles! Sad

Where did you find out? I am sure I have seen it lately at the Maison Guerlain parlour at KaDeWe in Berlin.

Greysolon
Greysolon
873 Posts
GreysolonGreysolon 16.05.2013, 13:44
Sherapop wrote:
DieNase wrote:
"Infusion de Vétiver" - the vetiver kicks in very late, don't give up early.


I just got this one, and I have to say that I love it. I also got the bath gel and it is fantastic for a long, hot soak!

But I somewhat suspect that "Infusion de Vetiver" is the vetiver for vetiver haters because it seems quite low on that note relative to other colognes/perfumes said to be vetiver-centric. I smell a pretty hefty dose of tarragon, which is gorgeous to my nose... Cool


I went against my self imposed prohibition of blind buying and purchased Infusion de Vetiver under peer pressure from CoutureGuru. He said all the cool kids were spraying it, even Sherapop Wink
IdV is really a fantastic summer vetiver and I'm so happy I took the leap based, in part, on your review, Shera. You had me at the title, "Watery Leafy Green Vetiver". Now I don't have to miss Sycomore during the warm weather months.
I haven't seen mention of Diptyque Vetyverio in this thread. It shares many qualities with Sycomore. But Diptyque's signature warm spice accord may make this up front, statuesque take on vetiver a bit more approachable for some.
Right now I'm also enjoying Lubin "Le Vetiver Itasca". The vetiver is not the main event but its there with its unique ability to add strength and dimension while remaining open and airy. How does vetiver do that?

Aafridi
Aafridi
2 Posts
AafridiAafridi 01.03.2014, 14:24
At the moment I am enjoying the smell of:
1. Encre Noir by Lalique
2. Guerlain Vetiver
and desperate to get Bel Ami Vetiver by Hermes.

Hadrien
Hadrien
4 Posts
HadrienHadrien 12.03.2014, 17:34
Apicius, thank you for great post about possible reformulation Guerlain's Vetiver.

Now the question is do I need the new bottle if I already have the ribbed bottle...

...and Vetiver extreme and Goutal's Vetiver and Villoresi's Vetiver, Encre noir, Fat electrician, Vettiveru and many more perfumes with strong vetiver note.

Answer is probably yes.

Deefit
Deefit
25 Posts
DeefitDeefit 14.03.2014, 01:16
My favorite would have to be TF's Grey Vetiver. Clean and not as dirty as many of the others mentioned before. But that's what I love about it. It's a very versatile scent.

Omni
Omni
235 Posts
OmniOmni 14.03.2014, 02:00
Chopard make a Noble Vetiver and a Noble Cedar. My husband tends to wear the latter, very strongly featuring vetiver anyway, on beach walks, where traces of it whip around in the wind. Very nice, but not at all strong in terms of sillage and projection.

Apicius
Apicius
3421 Posts
ApiciusApicius Guerlain vintage 03.04.2014, 02:23
I could not resist!

I spent 260 € on a 200 ml splash bottle of Guerlain's vintage Vetiver EdT on ebay.

As I could have forseen, it is quite rotten. I get a slight whiff of the old Vetiver during the first seconds after application, then some spice and leather take over with vetiver notes stepping aside. After an hour or so, some Vetiver comes back, but something else is missing, maybe the mossy side it once had? The vibe of the vintage does not fully break through, and longevity is reduced to about 3 hours,

A nice bottle for the shelf, though.

Display posts from previous:  

Foren-Übersicht Men's Perfume So many great vetivers...

Page 2 of 3