Seeking review advice - update or replace?
11 years ago
I would like your thoughts:
We're finally in the midst of warm, humid, summer like weather so I'm giving a second chance to a few fragrances I reviewed -and panned- during the cold, dry winter months. I had a feeling they would perform better once it warmed up but I'm surprised just how much some have improved as the season changes.
This is why I seeking advice:
Do you think it's better to simply edit the original review? This approach may help highlight the substantial seasonal difference for readers. I would, of course, acknowledge that the review has been edited.
Or...
Do you think it's more fair to perfumer and company to delete and a replace the original review? This approach may be more accurate since the seasonal difference might be an idiosyncrasy particular to me. I would, of course, acknowledge the seasonal difference.
We're finally in the midst of warm, humid, summer like weather so I'm giving a second chance to a few fragrances I reviewed -and panned- during the cold, dry winter months. I had a feeling they would perform better once it warmed up but I'm surprised just how much some have improved as the season changes.
This is why I seeking advice:
Do you think it's better to simply edit the original review? This approach may help highlight the substantial seasonal difference for readers. I would, of course, acknowledge that the review has been edited.
Or...
Do you think it's more fair to perfumer and company to delete and a replace the original review? This approach may be more accurate since the seasonal difference might be an idiosyncrasy particular to me. I would, of course, acknowledge the seasonal difference.